The fit between Eugenio Suarez and the Reds (through a 2025 lens)

Former Cincinnati Reds star Eugenio Suarez is current Cincinnati Reds star Eugenio Suarez, or will be when the ink on his $15 million deal goes dry. The two sides reportedly reunited on Sunday evening, and we’ve spent the last day excitedly wondering just how things are going to shake out as a result.

Suarez, of course, is a 3B by trade, a move decided upon by the Reds back in the day after the former shortstop showed he was much more suited for a role at the hot corner. That’s the role in which he was playing when the Reds signed him to his most recently completed contract back in early 2018, too, meaning this Reds club is pretty much the only team that’s ever talked him into signing big-dollar contracts in his career.

So, there’s already a ton of understanding between the two, something that’s clear given that the Reds other most recent big-money move was to acquire fellow 3B Ke’Bryan Hayes from Pittsburgh last trade deadline and have him on the books through at least 2029 for $36 million. Hayes, who is perhaps the best defender at any position in the sport, is going to defend the hot corner more often than not, so for Suarez to agree to this deal with Cincinnati means there had to be some air-clearing about his role on the upcoming squad.

That will likely be as the DH most days, with the idea that maybe, just maybe, he’ll get time at 3B and 1B here and there (barring an injury that renders all of this moot). That’s a plan that sounds eerily similar to that of top prospect Sal Stewart, too, though Stewart – who has reportedly lost 20 lbs since the end of last season – may end up getting some run at 2B, too. That’s a lot of 1B overlap already, of course, though neither Suarez nor Stewart has ever truly played there much at all – and that’s all despite resident 1B regular Spencer Steer still very much being on the roster, too.

While that seems like a logjam, let’s put some of that into context by using the 2025 Reds and how they shook out under manager Terry Francona.

For one, Gavin Lux has already been dealt away, and he got 57 starts at DH, 23 between 2B/3B, and 49 in LF. He logged 503 PA across all of those spots that someone else is going to get to eat into. It’s also easy to forget that Santiago Espinal (328 PA), Miguel Andujar (110 PA after coming over at the deadline), Austin Hays (416 PA), and Jake Fraley (193 PA) all factored into the equation at corner infield and corner outfield positions.

Connor Joe got 70 PA! Rece Hinds got 44! Christian Encarnacion-Strand somehow got 137 PA last year despite that feeling, in hindsight, more like about 15. The team also somehow managed to get Blake Dunn, Garrett Hampson, Jacob Hurtubise, Tyler Callihan, and Ryan Vilade a combined 115 PA, and that’s all after we easily forget the 91 PA given to Jeimer Candelario before he was mercifully let go.

A full season of Hayes, who got 178 PA after coming over, will consume a good portion of that. A full season at the big league level from Stewart will, too. Still, it seems quite likely that we’ll see Steer effectively assume the role vacated by Lux offensively while also providing better defense than the former at just about every position they both play. That could well lead to new acquisition JJ Bleday sitting on the bench a lot more than we thought he might all of two days ago, but considering he’s a reclamation project (who still has a minor league option), that’s not exactly a bad thing – if anything, it means that a reclamation project brought in by the Reds will now actually have to show he’s worth being reclaimed before simply being handed the role, something that wasn’t at all the case with the likes of Hays, Wil Myers, and others in recent years.

The hope, obviously, is that the Geno that mashed with Arizona (and who mashed with the Reds the first time around) is who the Reds just signed for the 2026 season. And, if that’s the case, there’s a path to 600+ PA for him without truly impeding anyone who will be better than him offensively in the process. If, for whatever reason, he’s more of the guy who struggled in the awful hitting environment in Seattle, though, the Reds have baked-in a whole lot of extra, quality depth to make sure Suarez’s struggles wouldn’t be enough to singlehandedly sink the Reds ship.

Yeah, there’s a lot of overlap on-paper here. As Steer’s shoulder, TJ Friedl’s wrist and hamstring, Hays’ everything, CES’s wrist, Matt McLain’s oblique/shoulder, and Fraley’s hammies will attest to, having that kind of overlap when you plan to embark upon playing baseball at the highest level every single day for seven months is a very good thing to have. And now, the Reds have the best bubbles in the business squarely in the middle of it all.