What is the single biggest “what if” moment in Bayern Munich’s history?

Every great club is built not only on trophies and triumphs, but also on the thin margins that could have changed everything. Bayern Munich’s glittering history is full of silverware, yet it also contains a handful of lingering “what if?” moments that continue to spark debate among supporters.

The most obvious starting point is the 1999 Champions League final. Bayern Munich was seconds away from lifting the trophy in Barcelona before Manchester United’s stoppage-time double turned certainty into heartbreak. What if the final whistle had blown just a minute earlier? Does the emotional arc that fueled the 2001 redemption ever happen the same way?

Another fascinating sliding-doors moment is the 2012 Champions League final at the Allianz Arena. Bayern Munich dominated Chelsea for long stretches yet lost on penalties in their own stadium. Had that night ended differently, would the legendary 2013 treble season still have materialized—or did the pain of 2012 forge the mentality that made it possible?

Transfer history offers its own alternate realities. What if Toni Kroos had never been sold to Real Madrid in 2014? Bayern still achieved enormous success, but Kroos became a central figure in multiple Champions League titles elsewhere. Similarly, what if Robert Lewandowski’s peak years had been paired with one more European triumph, particularly during the pandemic-affected seasons that denied Bayern a normal title defense?

Even managerial decisions invite speculation. What if Pep Guardiola had stayed longer, or what if Jupp Heynckes had continued after 2013? Each era reshaped Bayern’s identity, and small timing shifts might have produced very different European narratives.

That’s the beauty of a club like Bayern Munich: dominance doesn’t erase curiosity. Instead, success makes the near-misses feel even more intriguing.

So here’s the Question of the Day: What is the single biggest “What If” moment in Bayern Munich’s history—and how differently might the club look today if it had gone the other way?

If you are looking for more Bayern Munich and German national team coverage, check out the latest episodes of Bavarian Podcast Works, which you can get on Acast, Spotify, Apple, or any leading podcast distributor…

Join the conversation!

Sign up for a user account and get:

• New, improved notifications system!
• Fewer ads
• Create community posts
• Comment on articles, community posts
• Rec comments, community posts